• Institute
    • Leadership
    • Committees
      • Academic Advisory Board
        • Members' List since 1981
      • Board of Trustees
      • Members' Assembly
    • Contact Persons
    • The Kolleg
      • History
        • History of the Institute
          • History of the Kolleg
        • History of the Buildings and Gardens
          • Hauptgebäude
            • Excursus - Villa Linde's Grounds
          • Weiße Villa
          • Neubau
          • Villa Jaffé
          • Villa Walther
        • History of the Signet
      • Funding & Charters
        • Foundation Deed of the Ernst Reuter Foundation for Advanced Study
        • Charter of the Wissenschaftskolleg
      • Donors & Friends
    • Initiatives & Cooperations
      • Working Futures
        • Interviews
          • Gabriel Abend
          • Ève Chiapello
          • Elena Esposito
          • Michel Lallement
          • Sophie Bernard
          • David Stark
          • Richard Swedberg
        • Publications
          • Shifting Categories
          • Wiko Briefs - Working Futures in Corona Times
            • The digital transformation of work. COVID-19 as a taste of things to come?
            • Thinking the Global Rise of Forced Labor: Old, New, and Changing Forms of Labor Exploitation in Times of Crisis
            • Rearticulating globalization, solidarities, and work in Ethiopia
            • The future of shopping - Corona as a catalyst for the transformation of work
            • The End of the Pandemic of Productivism?
            • Covid and Looking for the Exit
            • Who or what is being tested in pandemic times?
            • The Crisis as Beginning of a New Relationship to the Professional World?
            • Controlled Avalanche – A Regulated Voluntary Exposure Approach for Addressing Covid-19
            • Caring about what we hold dear and the final purposes of work
            • How does the Corona crisis affect the future of work and our view of it?
            • "Useful", "indispensable", “essential”: Is the health crisis changing the categories with which we consider professional activities?
            • The Corona Crisis Reveals the Struggle for a Sustainable Digital Future
            • The Need for De-Integration in Pandemic Times
            • The COVID 19 crisis accelerates structural change in the world of work
            • How can we strengthen the contributory logic of work?
        • Events
        • Network
      • Blankensee-Colloquia
      • Anna Krüger Foundation
      • Some Institutes for Advanced Study (SIAS)
      • Support for Ukraine
      • VUIAS
        • Bilder der Eröffnungsfeier
      • Elkana Fellowships
    • Library
      • Ordering and Borrowing
      • Research
        • Journals and Newspapers
        • Catalogs
        • Specialised Information Services (Fachinformationsdienste)
        • Archives
      • Books & Music on-site
      • Questions?
  • Fellows
    • Fellow Finder
    • Fellows 2024/2025
    • Fellows 2025/2026
    • Permanent Fellows
      • Former Permanent Fellows
    • Alumni
      • Fellows' Club
        • Club
          • History
        • Membership
        • Newsletter
          • March 2025
            • Editorial
            • Architecture of Survival: An Interview with Natalia Romik (Elkana Fellow 2024/2025)
            • “Definitions Are Not Ultimate Truths”
            • Further Videos in the Wikotheque
            • The School of Human Rights Association: Building an Egalitarian and Democratic Academia in Turkey
            • Academic Freedom on a Small Scale
            • Save the Date: Annual Meeting of the Fellows’ Club
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • February 2024
            • Editorial
            • Feeding the World with Edible Insects
            • Schöner Leben
            • Further Videos in the Wikotheque
            • Conversation with a Left-Handed Hairdresser: The Cutting-Edge Sociology of Barbara Thériault (Fellow 2023/24)
            • Dishes that Raise Questions: Interview with chef de cuisine Sonja Frühsammer
            • Round and round the Grunewald Lake: Five Years of Wicked Wiko Runners
            • Save the Date – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2024
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • February 2023
            • Editorial
            • History Teacher of the People
            • War and Peace. The Past and Future of Ukraine
            • Cold, Ashamed, Relieved: On Leaving Russia
            • Music of a Refugee
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2023
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • March 2022
            • Editorial
            • Politics, Law, and Science in Times of the Pandemic
            • Pandemics: The Maths, the Masks, the Madness
            • Roni Taharlev: The Harbinger of Corona
            • Rachel Wheatley: Berlin with a Mask
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2022
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • February 2021
            • Editorial
            • Between Eigenzeit and Interdisciplinarity
            • The Masked Kolleg Unmasked
            • Was war und zu welchem Ende studiert man Trumpismus?
            • When Computers Took Their First Steps
            • A Farewell to Sonja Grund
            • Angelika Leuchter
            • Blog Series on Academic Freedom
            • Save the dates – Meetings of the Fellows’ Club 2021 and 2022
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club!
            • Obituaries
          • March 2020
            • Editorial
            • Constitution as Nonviolent Revolution
            • Imre Kertész und die europäische Literatur der Gegenwart
            • A Profound Sense of Loss
            • The Wissenschaftskolleg and the East: The New Europe College in Bucharest
            • Save the date - Meeting of the Fellows’ Club - Biodiversity: Conceptual Challenges in an Era of Rapid Change, June 11 and 12, 2020
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Obituarium
          • March 2019
            • Editorial
            • Paintings for the Future
            • Landmark Papers Revisited
            • Working Futures
            • Society Benefits From Our Autonomy
            • Two Million Blossoms in a Jar
            • Save the Date - Meeting of the Fellows' Club: June 13-14, 2019
            • Lectures on Film
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows' Club
            • Obituaries
          • March 2018
            • Editorial
            • A Good Bet: Five Years of the College for Life Sciences
            • Lectures on Film: Lisa Herzog
            • Return to Gdańsk
            • Sign the Gdansk Petition
            • Lecture Series: "Recht und Digitalisierung"
            • The Future of the Humboldt Forum: An Epiphany
            • (Almost) A Lifer
            • Late Checkout
            • Save the Date - Fellowtreffen
            • Prizes
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Obi­tu­a­ri­um
          • March 2017
            • Editorial
            • Luca Giuliani: Facets of Stephen
            • Berliner Abend 2017
            • Michael Jennions: Walking Berlin
            • Nostalgia
            • Prizes
          • June 2016
            • Editorial
            • Daniel M. Weary: Three days at Wiko to imagine a new world
            • Katharina Wiedemann: Travelling Lights
            • Wiliam Marx (fr)
            • Luc Steels: Grunewaldkirche, Bach, and Passions
            • Nostalgia
          • June 2015
            • Editorial
            • Adam S. Wilkins: Humanities and Natural Sciences
            • Rob Page: The Decline of the Humanities?
            • Alfons Söllner: From "Exilforschung" to "Emigrationsforschung"? A Journey in Memory.
            • Susan Rose-Ackerman and Bruce Ackerman: Wiko Then and Now: 1991-1992 and 2014-2015
            • Daniel Schönpflug: Ins Grüne
          • December 2014
            • Editorial
            • Sebastian Conrad: Global History
            • Sahotra Sarkar, Chris Margules: Biodiversity group at the Kolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: On Uwe Pörksen: Camelot im Grunewald. Szenen aus dem intellektuellen Leben der achtziger Jahre
            • Meredith Reiches: "Literary studies and biology: The Shakespeare-Workshops at the Kolleg 2012 and 2013"
            • Simon Teuscher: Workshop: Perspectives on Actors in Social History
            • Gebhard Kirchgässner: Workshop “The Economic Model of Human Behaviour”
            • Gerald Wilkinson: Workshop “Mind the Gap: Closing the Gulf between Genomic and Phenotypic Studies of Sexual Selection”
            • Sonja Grund: News from the Fellows’ Club
          • May 2014
            • Editorial
            • Peter Reill: From the Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin to Wiko: Reflections on a Return after Twenty-Seven Years
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus:Why artists are needed at research institutions
            • Martin Loughlin: Constitutions beyond the Nation-State
            • Franco Moretti: Invisible objects
            • Stefanie Rentsch: The Forum Transregionale Studien – its Mission and History
          • November 2013
            • Editorial
            • Jim Hunt: Ten Years in the Rearview Mirror
            • Thorsten Wilhelmy: My First Year at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Giovanni Frazzetto: The College for Life Sciences at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: The Fellow Forum for Former Fellows
      • Fellow Forum
  • Events
    • Calendar of Events
    • Workshops
    • Series of Events
      • Lecture Recitals
      • Zur Zeit
      • Observatorium
      • Ernst Mayr Lecture
    • Three Cultures Forum
  • Wikotheque
    • Wiko Shorts
    • Lectures & Keynotes
    • Features
    • Köpfe und Ideen
    • Projects
    • Yearbook
    • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte
  • Becoming a Fellow
    • Fellowship Applications
      • Preconditions
      • Selection Criteria
      • Selection Procedure
      • FAQ
    • Wiko Early Career Calls
      • Early Career Call Humanities and Social Sciences
        • Application and Selection
        • Eligibility
        • FAQ
      • Early Career Call Life and Natural Sciences
    • Living and Working
      • Financial Arrangements
      • Housing
      • Academic Life
      • Services
      • Services for Partners and Families
image/svg+xml
DeutschEnglish
 Login


MENU

  • Institute
  • Fellows
  • Events
  • Wikotheque
  • Becoming a Fellow

  • Wiko Shorts
  • Lectures & Keynotes
  • Features
  • Köpfe und Ideen
  • Projects
  • Yearbook
  • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte

Köpfe und Ideen 2017

Issue 12 / June 2017

Bonjour Tristan

by Hans-Joachim Neubauer

Julia Voss investigates the life and work of the Swedish painter Hilma af Klint

First let’s say hi to Tristan Otto. The tyrannosaur, or rather his black skeleton, is at the back of the first floor of Berlin’s Naturkundemuseum and he’s brandishing his chops. These must have left quite an impression 66 million years ago. Julia Voss tilts back her head – the twenty-first century meets the Cretaceous period. A sign explains that the 12-meter-long giant was named for the owner’s sons. Voss grabs her cellphone and starts googling. It turns out that Tristan belongs to a pair of London investment bankers. New money for old bones. Can a fossil serve as metaphor? And if so then what might it stand for? The financial system? Voss laughs, tucks her cell away, and moves on in sneakers of silver, orange and green. Evolution is most definitely more than just a theory about the past.

Julia Voss is culture & entertainment editor of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung. The Wissenschaftskolleg invited the art critic to Berlin to work on her book on the Swedish painter Hilma af Klint, an early abstract artist and for too long an unappreciated genius. Today she is a thorn in the side of art historians. But what are we doing here with Tristan? And what can we learn from the long extinct Tasmanian tiger? Tristan and the tiger are testimony to the course of evolution. Variation, natural selection – paleobiologists tell stories of way back when, their subject is earthly life, its origins and development. And Julia Voss has investigated just how that greatest of all naturalist narrators, Charles Darwin, conveyed his tale to the world. By means of pictures. Art history as epistemic science. Voss is assistant departmental manager of her newspaper, also honorary professor in Lüneburg, but among the dinosaurs she’s equally in her element.

Behind the glass cabinet containing the stuffed Tasmanian tiger is a plaster cast of the master himself. In the adjacent cabinet is a diagram of the human genome with all manner of data pertaining to our central code. A young girl and boy pass by, they marvel at Darwin’s beard, then continue on their way. Voss explains how Darwin thought and worked, how he developed the evolutionary model parallel to and then in tandem with Alfred Russel Wallace. She has had an intimate acquaintance with Darwin for a very long time now. She did research on him at the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science and in 2005 received her doctorate from Humboldt-Universität for a dissertation on the debate over Darwinism, a study which gained her the coveted Otto Hahn Medal. In 2007 she published Darwins Bilder. Ansichten der Evolutionstheorie 1837–1874 (Darwin’s Pictures: Views of Evolutionary Theory 1837-1874). Just read the book and you’ll grasp the extent to which the British naturalist used pictures in conceiving his theories. These photos, engravings, drawings and sketches impact our image of the story of life on earth to this very day.

In her book, from a completely new standpoint, Voss relates the mental journey traveled by this bold and liberating thinker. So it’s no accident that we now pay a visit to the crested argus, cousin of the great argus. We behold the animal’s luxuriant plumage and Voss explains how Darwin, in the second edition of his Descent of Man, presented argus males in the midst of their courtship displays together with hens not so as to illustrate the entrancing beauty of these creatures but to serve as visual models for the phenomenon of natural selection. In contrast to the strutting males the females appear very plain – but in truth it is they who are the true agents of the selection process, it is they who have the power of choice. In picking a partner they employ their taste in what strikes them as beautiful. But doesn’t everyone know that? Voss says: Today they do! Voss explains the care with which the media-strategist Darwin chose his pictures. Also as an illustration the great argus had to go through a tough selection process. It is one of the very few motifs Darwin employed to illustrate natural selection. This founder of modern evolutionary biology purposely avoided blood-soaked pictures of predators and their victims. For Darwin natural selection was not what later social Darwinists would regard as a battle between individuals where only the strongest win out. No – Charles Darwin’s natural selection was based on variation. Those animals which best adapt to their environment are the ones that flourish. Only the beautiful cocks become fathers. In the subtitle to his Descent of Man, Darwin called this phenomenon “Selection in Relation to Sex.” Adaptation instead of optimization. Tristan might be big, but he’s dead.

Julia Voss walks through the Naturkundemuseum and the objects begin to speak. That’s simply what transpires when a historian of art and science checks out her surroundings. Exhibits are given a context. “That’s the most beautiful one,” says Voss pointing at a glass case. We are standing before a reproduction of Darwin’s famous tree-of-life sketch from 1837, his very first. Beneath the words “I think” he drew a few lines to sketch an abstracted genealogical tree and thereby illustrate the evolutionary principle – with the letters A, B, C and D standing for the various species. A eureka moment in the history of biology. This page from Darwin’s notebook signaled the triumphal procession of a metaphor, of a model, of a picture illustrating an idea. The words “I think” at apex of the sketch are the quintessence of that species which lays claim to the very top branch of the tree of life. “It almost looks like conceptual art,” says Voss, “an epistemically beautiful moment.”

Beautiful episteme: In the grandiose in-vitro hall of the museum we see creatures preserved in alcohol, livid representatives of their respective species, thousands of dead witnesses to life’s diversity. “Disorder,” says Voss, “that’s nature.” These naked and lonely creatures in their glass jars are an outlandish sight. The many kids making a happy racket in other parts of the museum are suddenly much quieter when they enter this hall. A reflective moment? Voss says that Darwin at least had respect for religion and didn’t see himself as its opponent. Then she recalls that time when she traveled to Santee, California, not far from San Diego, to visit the Museum of Creation and Earth History, which might be termed the religious counterpart to our present venue. Bible-abiding creationists believe that the earth is between 4000 and 6000 years old. Voss asked one of them how Noah managed to get dinosaurs onto his ark, and the answer was not illogical – “In eggs!”

Later sitting on the big round sofa in the museum’s stairwell and the children are screaming and laughing again. And again, the disk with the outer-space film descends from above and hovers over twenty people seated on the sofa, going back in time, and then showing the universe. Two girls huddle together and gaze upward. Through half-closed eyes Voss glances their way: “Art museums can only dream of this kind of thing.” What thing? “This smell, this locker-room flair, the excitement, the squeak of sneakers on the floor.” Natural history museums are places for children, places of wonder and learning; art museums smell of perfume, gray hair and edification. Above us the cosmos prepares to descend on us and the countdown begins with the children counting along. Then comes the Big Bang. Billions of years pass in a matter of seconds while the children hold their breath. Voss tells of Hilma af Klint, of the symbols in her paintings, of her experiments with form, of the sheer size of her pictures. Klint was inspired by spiritual experiences and cosmological ponderings. “When you hang her paintings as they’re meant to be hung then you see that they compose series which describe certain developments. She transposed evolutionary thought to art.”

Supernovas lurch through chaos, boulders zinging about, comets on elliptical trajectories, disorder and disarray. “For Hilma af Klint not only does the organic world evolve but the cultural one as well – and its art along with it.” A few million years pass by, the two girls next to us are rapt. “Hilma af Klint was sure that she was the beginning. She was certain that someday the invisible worlds would be as clearly reproducible as the visible ones.” Insight into time then shifts into a view of space, the monitor screen slowly floating upward again. Candy wrappers fly through the air, microcosmos meets macrocosmos, universal order everywhere you look. Where are we and who are we? Voss brushes a strand of hair from her face. “Hilma realized that she was ahead of her time,” says Voss, “and she was right.”

Tristan is still standing there and being marveled at as one evolution’s tragic losers. His mission: to terrorize. His descendants: chickens. If he wasn’t so big then he likely wouldn’t even be here. What do we want to see? What not? What’s sensational, what will be forgotten? Hilma af Klint was doing abstract paintings as early as 1906, some years before Wassily Kandinsky and František Kupka. She kept her work under wraps and mandated that this should remain so for up until twenty years after her death. Does art without a market have any place in the canon? “When you have a Kandinsky going for 80 million, no one wants an outsider, some new Swedish woman, who undermines the whole story of men inventing abstract painting in 1910 and 1911. Voss wants to correct and expand the canon for Hilma af Klint. “Who writes art history and what are the interests involved?” Voss knows whereof she speaks. Together with her illustrator husband Philipp Deines she composed the book Hinter weißen Wänden: Behind the White Cube, a passionate meditation on the art market, the canon and criticism in times of big money. The market is hardly “natural” and not at all “evolved” but rather the result of uncompromisingly brokered interests. Survival of the fittest? Do only the best ever get ahead? “No”, Voss shakes her head. It’s not as simple as that. “The question is which narrative comes out on top and which doesn’t.” It’s worth inquiring as to the beneficiaries of the situation – as to the cui bono: “For just whom is the system designed?”

Bye-bye Tristan. Outside the spring weather is beckoning, Berlin is in a cheerful mood, and Voss must go. Her Swedish course begins in an hour. Next month she is traveling to Sweden to meet with Klint’s relatives and do research in the museums and archives. What would she ask the painter if she could somehow meet her there? Voss likes the question. “For one, I would ask her when exactly she took certain trips; that information is hard to gather.” And for another? A pause – then she laughs and says: “I think . . . I think I’d ask her what she thought of Wassily Kandinsky’s paintings.”

More on: Julia Voss

Images: © Maurice Weiss

Institute for Advanced Study

  • Press Releases
  • Contact Persons
  • Contact
  • Vacancies
  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap

Institute

  • Leadership
  • Committees
  • Contact Persons
  • The Kolleg
  • Initiatives & Cooperations
  • Library

Fellows

  • Fellow Finder
  • Fellows 2024/2025
  • Fellows 2025/2026
  • Permanent Fellows
  • Alumni

Events

  • Calendar of Events
  • Workshops
  • Series of Events
  • Three Cultures Forum

Wikotheque

  • Wiko Shorts
  • Lectures & Keynotes
  • Features
  • Köpfe und Ideen
  • Projects
  • Yearbook
  • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte

Becoming a Fellow

  • Fellowship Applications
  • Wiko Early Career Calls
  • Living and Working