• Institute
    • Leadership
    • Committees
      • Academic Advisory Board
        • Members' List since 1981
      • Board of Trustees
      • Members' Assembly
    • Contact Persons
    • The Kolleg
      • History
        • History of the Institute
          • History of the Kolleg
        • History of the Buildings and Gardens
          • Hauptgebäude
            • Excursus - Villa Linde's Grounds
          • Weiße Villa
          • Neubau
          • Villa Jaffé
          • Villa Walther
        • History of the Signet
      • Funding & Charters
        • Foundation Deed of the Ernst Reuter Foundation for Advanced Study
        • Charter of the Wissenschaftskolleg
      • Donors & Friends
    • Initiatives & Cooperations
      • Working Futures
        • Interviews
          • Gabriel Abend
          • Ève Chiapello
          • Elena Esposito
          • Michel Lallement
          • Sophie Bernard
          • David Stark
          • Richard Swedberg
        • Publications
          • Shifting Categories
          • Wiko Briefs - Working Futures in Corona Times
            • The digital transformation of work. COVID-19 as a taste of things to come?
            • Thinking the Global Rise of Forced Labor: Old, New, and Changing Forms of Labor Exploitation in Times of Crisis
            • Rearticulating globalization, solidarities, and work in Ethiopia
            • The future of shopping - Corona as a catalyst for the transformation of work
            • The End of the Pandemic of Productivism?
            • Covid and Looking for the Exit
            • Who or what is being tested in pandemic times?
            • The Crisis as Beginning of a New Relationship to the Professional World?
            • Controlled Avalanche – A Regulated Voluntary Exposure Approach for Addressing Covid-19
            • Caring about what we hold dear and the final purposes of work
            • How does the Corona crisis affect the future of work and our view of it?
            • "Useful", "indispensable", “essential”: Is the health crisis changing the categories with which we consider professional activities?
            • The Corona Crisis Reveals the Struggle for a Sustainable Digital Future
            • The Need for De-Integration in Pandemic Times
            • The COVID 19 crisis accelerates structural change in the world of work
            • How can we strengthen the contributory logic of work?
        • Events
        • Network
      • Blankensee-Colloquia
      • Anna Krüger Foundation
      • Some Institutes for Advanced Study (SIAS)
      • Ukraine Fellowships
      • Elkana Fellowships
    • Library
      • Ordering and Borrowing
      • Research
        • Journals and Newspapers
        • Catalogs
        • Specialised Information Services (Fachinformationsdienste)
        • Archives
      • Books & Music on-site
      • Questions?
  • Fellows
    • Fellowfinder
    • Fellows 2022/2023
    • Permanent Fellows
      • Former Permanent Fellows
    • Alumni
      • Fellows' Club
        • Club
          • History
        • Membership
        • Newsletter
          • February 2023
            • Editorial
            • History Teacher of the People
            • War and Peace. The Past and Future of Ukraine
            • Cold, Ashamed, Relieved: On Leaving Russia
            • Music of a Refugee
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2023
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • March 2022
            • Editorial
            • Politics, Law, and Science in Times of the Pandemic
            • Pandemics: The Maths, the Masks, the Madness
            • Roni Taharlev: The Harbinger of Corona
            • Rachel Wheatley: Berlin with a Mask
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2022
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • February 2021
            • Editorial
            • Between Eigenzeit and Interdisciplinarity
            • The Masked Kolleg Unmasked
            • Was war und zu welchem Ende studiert man Trumpismus?
            • When Computers Took Their First Steps
            • A Farewell to Sonja Grund
            • Angelika Leuchter
            • Blog Series on Academic Freedom
            • Save the dates – Meetings of the Fellows’ Club 2021 and 2022
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club!
            • Obituaries
          • March 2020
            • Editorial
            • Constitution as Nonviolent Revolution
            • Imre Kertész und die europäische Literatur der Gegenwart
            • A Profound Sense of Loss
            • The Wissenschaftskolleg and the East: The New Europe College in Bucharest
            • Save the date - Meeting of the Fellows’ Club - Biodiversity: Conceptual Challenges in an Era of Rapid Change, June 11 and 12, 2020
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Obituarium
          • March 2019
            • Editorial
            • Paintings for the Future
            • Landmark Papers Revisited
            • Working Futures
            • Society Benefits From Our Autonomy
            • Two Million Blossoms in a Jar
            • Save the Date - Meeting of the Fellows' Club: June 13-14, 2019
            • Lectures on Film
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows' Club
            • Obituaries
          • March 2018
            • Editorial
            • A Good Bet: Five Years of the College for Life Sciences
            • Lectures on Film: Lisa Herzog
            • Return to Gdańsk
            • Sign the Gdansk Petition
            • Lecture Series: "Recht und Digitalisierung"
            • The Future of the Humboldt Forum: An Epiphany
            • (Almost) A Lifer
            • Late Checkout
            • Save the Date - Fellowtreffen
            • Prizes
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Obi­tu­a­ri­um
          • March 2017
            • Editorial
            • Luca Giuliani: Facets of Stephen
            • Berliner Abend 2017
            • Michael Jennions: Walking Berlin
            • Nostalgia
            • Prizes
          • June 2016
            • Editorial
            • Daniel M. Weary: Three days at Wiko to imagine a new world
            • Katharina Wiedemann: Travelling Lights
            • Wiliam Marx (fr)
            • Luc Steels: Grunewaldkirche, Bach, and Passions
            • Nostalgia
          • June 2015
            • Editorial
            • Adam S. Wilkins: Humanities and Natural Sciences
            • Rob Page: The Decline of the Humanities?
            • Alfons Söllner: From "Exilforschung" to "Emigrationsforschung"? A Journey in Memory.
            • Susan Rose-Ackerman and Bruce Ackerman: Wiko Then and Now: 1991-1992 and 2014-2015
            • Daniel Schönpflug: Ins Grüne
          • December 2014
            • Editorial
            • Sebastian Conrad: Global History
            • Sahotra Sarkar, Chris Margules: Biodiversity group at the Kolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: On Uwe Pörksen: Camelot im Grunewald. Szenen aus dem intellektuellen Leben der achtziger Jahre
            • Meredith Reiches: "Literary studies and biology: The Shakespeare-Workshops at the Kolleg 2012 and 2013"
            • Simon Teuscher: Workshop: Perspectives on Actors in Social History
            • Gebhard Kirchgässner: Workshop “The Economic Model of Human Behaviour”
            • Gerald Wilkinson: Workshop “Mind the Gap: Closing the Gulf between Genomic and Phenotypic Studies of Sexual Selection”
            • Sonja Grund: News from the Fellows’ Club
          • May 2014
            • Editorial
            • Peter Reill: From the Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin to Wiko: Reflections on a Return after Twenty-Seven Years
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus:Why artists are needed at research institutions
            • Martin Loughlin: Constitutions beyond the Nation-State
            • Franco Moretti: Invisible objects
            • Stefanie Rentsch: The Forum Transregionale Studien – its Mission and History
          • November 2013
            • Editorial
            • Jim Hunt: Ten Years in the Rearview Mirror
            • Thorsten Wilhelmy: My First Year at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Giovanni Frazzetto: The College for Life Sciences at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: The Fellow Forum for Former Fellows
      • Fellow Forum
  • Events
    • Calendar of Events
    • Lecture Recitals
    • Zur Zeit
    • Observatorium
    • Ernst Mayr Lecture
    • Workshops
    • Three Cultures Forum
  • Wikotheque
    • Wiko Shorts
    • Lectures & Keynotes
    • Features
    • Köpfe und Ideen
    • Projects
    • Yearbook
    • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte
  • Becoming a Fellow
    • Fellowships
      • Individual Fellowships
        • Preconditions
        • Selection Criteria
        • Selection Procedure
        • FAQ
        • Application Platform
      • Focus Groups
        • Preconditions
        • Criteria
        • Procedures
          • Befangenheit im Auswahlprozess
        • Overview of Focus Groups
        • Current Call for Proposals
          • Instructions for Submitting a Proposal for a Focus Group
      • College for Life Sciences
        • Program
        • Application
        • Fellows
        • Scientific Committee
        • FAQ
    • Living and Working
      • Financial Arrangements
      • Housing
      • Academic Life
      • Services
      • Services for Partners and Families
Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin
DeutschEnglish
 Login


MENU

  • Institute
  • Fellows
  • Events
  • Wikotheque
  • Becoming a Fellow

  • Fellowfinder
  • Fellows 2022/2023
  • Permanent Fellows
  • Alumni

  • Fellows' Club
  • Fellow Forum

The Decline of the Humanities?

Rob Page

Simplicius, Philoponus, and the Red Queen

It started with Fellows Colloquium. I was sitting listening to yet another hour-long talk about Aristotle, read, without visual aids. One where, again, the talk began in the middle of a question without any background or explanation (at least not understandable to a biologist) as to why it was an important question or why anyone other than Aristotle scholars should care. When the obligatory question session opened, I asked my question, "Why were neoplatonists in the middle ages studying Aristotle?" I followed up with, "And why are you studying them?" I was serious but my question opened up a chasm showing huge differences between the humanities and sciences (I am a biologist) with respect to how we ask, investigate, and present the research findings of the questions of our disciplines. Subsequent comments increasingly pointed out that one shouldn't question knowledge. Knowledge for its own sake stands unchallenged. The discussion ended with someone standing up and saying something to the effect of "if we question such things we should just cut off our heads", I think he specifically meant mine

Of course this wasn't what I expected, in science we always begin our talks giving the background for a question and pointing out why it is important. We constantly defend our questions when we write grants attempting to get funds to support our research. Subsequently a group of social science fellows, who became and continue to be good friends, organized an evening event to discuss the differences in our methods, how we go about testing our ideas, and even how to use PowerPoint in a talk. Subsequent colloquia often began with "For Rob's benefit I have a couple of slides", and "this is an important question because...." In some sense I made an impact.

The Great Recession and the Decline of Humanities

I was in the Wiko class of 2009-2010, this was the dark age of the Great Recession. The general perception was that the humanities were being disproportionately negatively affected. In June 2013, I attended an annual conference of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation. I was invited to participate in a Round Table Discussion with other former Humboldt Research Prize Winners. The discussion was supposed to be about our Humboldt experiences and the development of Humboldt sponsorship programs in our home countries. The discussion quickly devolved into a litany of testimonials about the decline of the humanities in universities. At this time I was the Dean of the College of Liberal Arts and Science at ASU and I was struggling at the intersection of the "hard" sciences, social sciences, and humanities. I had been through major funding cuts making decisions on what to support and what to cut. When my turn came, I asked them why they were so negative. Many of them were from major universities of high prestige . Do you still have a tenured job guaranteed for life? Answer yes. Did you get pay cuts? Answer no. Do you still have graduate students, go to meetings around the world, get recognition from your peers? Answer yes, yes, and yes. But their chorus reminded me of the song by Warren Zevon, "Poor Poor Pitiful Me". Click on this link and hear the version sung by Linda Ronstadt, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cd2_LKoTYKw.

Was the decline real?

Were the woeful stories justified? ASU the largest public university in the U.S. and probably represents the trends that have taken place at many or most universities. The College of Liberal Arts and Sciences is the largest college at ASU and represents the humanities (HUM), social sciences (SS), and the natural, physical sciences, and mathematics (PHY). So, lets take a look at trends from before the recession until now. And lets also compare them with the schools of engineering at ASU (see table below).

Year200620072008200920102011201220132014Percent change 06-14

TT Faculty FTE1/

          
HUM164.7168.4178.0169.0183.5179.5176.5184.6176.0+6.9
SS216.2222.7219.5229.0258.5237.5231.3236.9218.2+1.0
LS99.093.391.393.898.898.393.992.591.1-7.9
PHY204.3203.2211.5215.8220.5220.5223.5237.5228.5+11.8
ENG208.4205.1204.9205.2209.7207.7219.0229.3246.3+18.2

Student FTE Delivered

          
HUM7,819.57,419.77,072.07,522.97,546.47,320.07,246.47,304.97,645.4-2.2
SS7,775.97,587.67,824.18,783.89,421.79,929.59,459.39,662.49,811.0+26.2
LS1,849.11,881.72,132.02,237.42,187.02,297.92,274.12,347.32,411.6+30.4
PHY6,774.76,840.87,319.97,766.67,886.98,913.28,866.79,287.49,964.4+47.1
ENG4,389.94,545.84,529.14,483.84,902.55,496.56,093.97,133.48,447.2+92.4

Student FTE/Faculty FTE

          
HUM25.824.322.826.325.024.824.821.922.0-14.7
SS30.928.529.630.128.731.130.329.730.6-1.0
LS15.217.419.820.819.920.621.521.723.3+53.3
PHY20.320.021.422.822.726.826.924.727.7+36.5
ENG16.017.216.617.418.922.123.525.427.4+71.2

1/TT Faculty FTE is the number of tenured faculty full time equivalents in the humanities (HUM), social sciences (SS), life sciences (LS), physical sciences including math (PHY), and engineering (ENG). Student FTE delivered is the number of student full time equivalents taking courses from all faculty, tenure track and contract. Student FTE/Faculty FTE is the number of student full time equivalents per faculty FTE, including all faculty TT and contract.

First of all, like so often happens in science, my initial assumptions were wrong. I expected a decline in student enrollment, and faculty in the humanities, and an increase in student to faculty ratios due to a steeper decline in faculty than in students. This is what I had been told repeatedly was happening. Instead, the humanities faculty FTE increased, student numbers decreased and the student to faculty ratios decreased nearly 30%. The overall large increase in student numbers in the STEM disciplines (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) was expected, but I was surprised by the extent to which we had failed to keep up with hiring faculty in those areas resulting in significant increases in teaching workloads. Teaching workloads in these disciplines are typically half those of the social sciences and humanities due to the research expectations placed on the faculty.

To answer the question: are the humanities declining at ASU, I would say no and yes. The faculty has not declined, in fact they are significantly overrepresented relative to the students and the rest of the university. Student numbers in the humanities have fallen far behind relative to the STEM disciplines and one might argue there are currently too many humanities faculty. Keep in mind that the student population at ASU has grown significantly during this time.

Are there Clear and Present Dangers?

The alarm is sounding from many quarters of Academe, suggesting that all is not right with the current perception of the value of the humanities. In 2013, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences issued a study titled "The Heart of the Matter" (http://illinois.edu/2882/the_heart_of_the_matter___report.pdf) , an attempt to show that the humanities have central importance to democracy, the economy, and leadership in a globalized world. Few questioned the relevance of an education in the humanities, until now. Within the last few years there was also an attempt to eliminate the social sciences from the funding budget of the National Science Foundation in the US (see page 53, http://www.nature.com/news/nsf-cancels-political-science-grant-cycle-1.13501). The academic community rallied to defend their existence, the funding was not cut. Natural and physical sciences are better at defending their relevance by showing the shift of students from the humanities to STEM disciplines, competing for grants that build university infrastructure, and by showing direct connections between their research and solving world problems. The social sciences also succeed better than the humanities. But the humanists (I know I am binning them all together and that isn't fair) remain in their silos daring others to question their relevance as the students and faculty drain away.

Last academic year the Board of Regents that oversees the three public universities in Arizona asked THE question. Why do we continue to give degrees in the liberal arts? (The liberal arts are often misrepresented as being only the social sciences and humanities, they were focused on the humanities.) This came soon after I assumed my new position as University Provost of ASU. The three provosts of the three public universities, including me, felt passionate about defending the importance of the humanities and prepared a defense. Keep in mind that none of us are humanists, the three of us are from the natural and physical sciences. A summary of the report can be found at: https://azregents.asu.edu/academicaffairs/Academic Affairs Agenda Books/2014-04-02 Minutes.pdf . The take home message is that the value of a liberal arts education is being discussed in major academic venues, congressional committees in the US that oversee public funded research, and in meetings of university governing boards that determine the directions of our public universities.

I think there are other indicators of clear and present danger to the humanities. The shift of students into professional schools reflects the rising opinion that an education prepares students for the workforce, rather than prepares them for a productive and meaningful life.

Another danger is the streamlining of the curriculum. Professional undergraduate programs like engineering already have cut the liberal part of the liberal arts general studies down to a minimum by increasing the number of required major subject courses. (I use "liberal" in the context of students having a liberal assortment of elective courses available to explore.) This has been due to the push by universities to deliver "lean" programs where all students take only the minimum number of credits (courses) required for graduation. This keeps the price per degree low, an important metric for governing boards and state legislators overseeing public universities. So, in general, course enrollments in the humanities and social sciences are reduced. But also in part because faculty outside of the humanities have lost their understanding of the value of a liberal education and think students are wasting time that could otherwise be spent taking more math, science, or professional subjects.

What now?

Going back to the discussions following the fellow's colloquium mentioned above, I felt that my humanist friends and colleagues were unprepared to explain why what they do is relevant. Not that they couldn't construct a believable argument, but that they didn't think they should have to. It sufficed to say knowledge for the sake of knowledge is enough. That was good in the past but we are now in the age of hyper-accountability. To survive and grow, the humanists need a coherent argument based on a return on investment. In my opinion that argument must look beyond the financial rewards of a degree and show how the return on liberal arts education is measured by the life story of those we educate. It should be easy.

  • Club
  • Membership
  • Newsletter
    • February 2023
    • March 2022
    • February 2021
    • March 2020
    • March 2019
    • March 2018
    • March 2017
    • June 2016
    • June 2015
      • Editorial
      • Adam S. Wilkins: Humanities and Natural Sciences
      • Rob Page: The Decline of the Humanities?
      • Alfons Söllner: From "Exilforschung" to "Emigrationsforschung"? A Journey in Memory.
      • Susan Rose-Ackerman and Bruce Ackerman: Wiko Then and Now: 1991-1992 and 2014-2015
      • Daniel Schönpflug: Ins Grüne
    • December 2014
    • May 2014
    • November 2013

Institute for Advanced Study

  • Twitter
  • Press Releases
  • Contact Persons
  • Contact
  • Vacancies
  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap

Institute

  • Leadership
  • Committees
  • Contact Persons
  • The Kolleg
  • Initiatives & Cooperations
  • Library

Fellows

  • Fellowfinder
  • Fellows 2022/2023
  • Permanent Fellows
  • Alumni

Events

  • Calendar of Events
  • Lecture Recitals
  • Zur Zeit
  • Observatorium
  • Ernst Mayr Lecture
  • Workshops
  • Three Cultures Forum

Wikotheque

  • Wiko Shorts
  • Lectures & Keynotes
  • Features
  • Köpfe und Ideen
  • Projects
  • Yearbook
  • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte

Becoming a Fellow

  • Fellowships
  • Living and Working