• Institute
    • Leadership
    • Committees
      • Academic Advisory Board
        • Members' List since 1981
      • Board of Trustees
      • Members' Assembly
    • Contact Persons
    • The Kolleg
      • History
        • History of the Institute
          • History of the Kolleg
        • History of the Buildings and Gardens
          • Hauptgebäude
            • Excursus - Villa Linde's Grounds
          • Weiße Villa
          • Neubau
          • Villa Jaffé
          • Villa Walther
        • History of the Signet
      • Funding & Charters
        • Foundation Deed of the Ernst Reuter Foundation for Advanced Study
        • Charter of the Wissenschaftskolleg
      • Donors & Friends
    • Initiatives & Cooperations
      • Working Futures
        • Interviews
          • Gabriel Abend
          • Ève Chiapello
          • Elena Esposito
          • Michel Lallement
          • Sophie Bernard
          • David Stark
          • Richard Swedberg
        • Publications
          • Shifting Categories
          • Wiko Briefs - Working Futures in Corona Times
            • The digital transformation of work. COVID-19 as a taste of things to come?
            • Thinking the Global Rise of Forced Labor: Old, New, and Changing Forms of Labor Exploitation in Times of Crisis
            • Rearticulating globalization, solidarities, and work in Ethiopia
            • The future of shopping - Corona as a catalyst for the transformation of work
            • The End of the Pandemic of Productivism?
            • Covid and Looking for the Exit
            • Who or what is being tested in pandemic times?
            • The Crisis as Beginning of a New Relationship to the Professional World?
            • Controlled Avalanche – A Regulated Voluntary Exposure Approach for Addressing Covid-19
            • Caring about what we hold dear and the final purposes of work
            • How does the Corona crisis affect the future of work and our view of it?
            • "Useful", "indispensable", “essential”: Is the health crisis changing the categories with which we consider professional activities?
            • The Corona Crisis Reveals the Struggle for a Sustainable Digital Future
            • The Need for De-Integration in Pandemic Times
            • The COVID 19 crisis accelerates structural change in the world of work
            • How can we strengthen the contributory logic of work?
        • Events
        • Network
      • Blankensee-Colloquia
        • Call for Papers
      • Anna Krüger Foundation
      • Some Institutes for Advanced Study (SIAS)
      • Ukraine Fellowships
      • Elkana Fellowships
    • Library
      • Ordering and Borrowing
      • Research
        • Journals and Newspapers
        • Catalogs
        • Specialised Information Services (Fachinformationsdienste)
        • Archives
      • Books & Music on-site
      • Questions?
  • Fellows
    • Fellowfinder
    • Fellows 2022/2023
    • Permanent Fellows
      • Former Permanent Fellows
    • Alumni
      • Fellows' Club
        • Club
          • History
        • Membership
        • Newsletter
          • February 2023
            • Editorial
            • History Teacher of the People
            • War and Peace. The Past and Future of Ukraine
            • Cold, Ashamed, Relieved: On Leaving Russia
            • Music of a Refugee
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2023
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • March 2022
            • Editorial
            • Politics, Law, and Science in Times of the Pandemic
            • Pandemics: The Maths, the Masks, the Madness
            • Roni Taharlev: The Harbinger of Corona
            • Rachel Wheatley: Berlin with a Mask
            • A Word from the Chairman
            • Save the dates – Meeting of the Fellows’ Club 2022
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Membership Fee and Donations
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Obituaries
          • February 2021
            • Editorial
            • Between Eigenzeit and Interdisciplinarity
            • The Masked Kolleg Unmasked
            • Was war und zu welchem Ende studiert man Trumpismus?
            • When Computers Took Their First Steps
            • A Farewell to Sonja Grund
            • Angelika Leuchter
            • Blog Series on Academic Freedom
            • Save the dates – Meetings of the Fellows’ Club 2021 and 2022
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club!
            • Obituaries
          • March 2020
            • Editorial
            • Constitution as Nonviolent Revolution
            • Imre Kertész und die europäische Literatur der Gegenwart
            • A Profound Sense of Loss
            • The Wissenschaftskolleg and the East: The New Europe College in Bucharest
            • Save the date - Meeting of the Fellows’ Club - Biodiversity: Conceptual Challenges in an Era of Rapid Change, June 11 and 12, 2020
            • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows’ Club
            • Obituarium
          • March 2019
            • Editorial
            • Paintings for the Future
            • Landmark Papers Revisited
            • Working Futures
            • Society Benefits From Our Autonomy
            • Two Million Blossoms in a Jar
            • Save the Date - Meeting of the Fellows' Club: June 13-14, 2019
            • Lectures on Film
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Prizes
            • Join the Fellows' Club
            • Obituaries
          • March 2018
            • Editorial
            • A Good Bet: Five Years of the College for Life Sciences
            • Lectures on Film: Lisa Herzog
            • Return to Gdańsk
            • Sign the Gdansk Petition
            • Lecture Series: "Recht und Digitalisierung"
            • The Future of the Humboldt Forum: An Epiphany
            • (Almost) A Lifer
            • Late Checkout
            • Save the Date - Fellowtreffen
            • Prizes
            • New Publications in the Fellows' Library
            • Obi­tu­a­ri­um
          • March 2017
            • Editorial
            • Luca Giuliani: Facets of Stephen
            • Berliner Abend 2017
            • Michael Jennions: Walking Berlin
            • Nostalgia
            • Prizes
          • June 2016
            • Editorial
            • Daniel M. Weary: Three days at Wiko to imagine a new world
            • Katharina Wiedemann: Travelling Lights
            • Wiliam Marx (fr)
            • Luc Steels: Grunewaldkirche, Bach, and Passions
            • Nostalgia
          • June 2015
            • Editorial
            • Adam S. Wilkins: Humanities and Natural Sciences
            • Rob Page: The Decline of the Humanities?
            • Alfons Söllner: From "Exilforschung" to "Emigrationsforschung"? A Journey in Memory.
            • Susan Rose-Ackerman and Bruce Ackerman: Wiko Then and Now: 1991-1992 and 2014-2015
            • Daniel Schönpflug: Ins Grüne
          • December 2014
            • Editorial
            • Sebastian Conrad: Global History
            • Sahotra Sarkar, Chris Margules: Biodiversity group at the Kolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: On Uwe Pörksen: Camelot im Grunewald. Szenen aus dem intellektuellen Leben der achtziger Jahre
            • Meredith Reiches: "Literary studies and biology: The Shakespeare-Workshops at the Kolleg 2012 and 2013"
            • Simon Teuscher: Workshop: Perspectives on Actors in Social History
            • Gebhard Kirchgässner: Workshop “The Economic Model of Human Behaviour”
            • Gerald Wilkinson: Workshop “Mind the Gap: Closing the Gulf between Genomic and Phenotypic Studies of Sexual Selection”
            • Sonja Grund: News from the Fellows’ Club
          • May 2014
            • Editorial
            • Peter Reill: From the Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin to Wiko: Reflections on a Return after Twenty-Seven Years
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus:Why artists are needed at research institutions
            • Martin Loughlin: Constitutions beyond the Nation-State
            • Franco Moretti: Invisible objects
            • Stefanie Rentsch: The Forum Transregionale Studien – its Mission and History
          • November 2013
            • Editorial
            • Jim Hunt: Ten Years in the Rearview Mirror
            • Thorsten Wilhelmy: My First Year at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Giovanni Frazzetto: The College for Life Sciences at the Wissenschaftskolleg
            • Reinhart Meyer-Kalkus: The Fellow Forum for Former Fellows
      • Fellow Forum
  • Events
    • Calendar of Events
    • Lecture Recitals
    • Zur Zeit
    • Observatorium
    • Ernst Mayr Lecture
    • Workshops
    • Three Cultures Forum
  • Wikotheque
    • Wiko Shorts
    • Lectures & Keynotes
    • Features
    • Köpfe und Ideen
    • Projects
    • Yearbook
    • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte
  • Becoming a Fellow
    • Fellowships
      • Individual Fellowships
        • Preconditions
        • Selection Criteria
        • Selection Procedure
        • FAQ
        • Application Platform
      • Focus Groups
        • Preconditions
        • Criteria
        • Procedures
          • Befangenheit im Auswahlprozess
        • Overview of Focus Groups
      • College for Life Sciences
        • Program
        • Application
        • Fellows
        • Scientific Committee
        • FAQ
    • Living and Working
      • Financial Arrangements
      • Housing
      • Academic Life
      • Services
      • Services for Partners and Families
Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin
DeutschEnglish
 Login


MENU

  • Institute
  • Fellows
  • Events
  • Wikotheque
  • Becoming a Fellow

  • Fellowfinder
  • Fellows 2022/2023
  • Permanent Fellows
  • Alumni

  • Fellows' Club
  • Fellow Forum

A Profound Sense of Loss

Karolina Wigura and Jarosław Kuisz on political emotions in Poland since 1989

It’s a good thing that the thirtieth jubilee of the political turnaround of 1989 is finally ending. For some Poles, it was hard to bear. The memories of joyful moments have been buried under bitterness about the current situation.

Explanations for the disappointment about the democratic turnaround in the former Warsaw Pact have been sought for a long time. Political, economic, and cultural reasons for post-communist populism have been named. In Poland, the decision for a radical liberalization of the economy is most frequently criticized. Only recently have cultural resentments been added to that. For example, east German AfD voters have said their sympathies are because people “from the West” still treat them like “second-class citizens”. Quite apart from whether it is true or not, in Eastern Europe a mood predominates that makes it impossible to feel unmixed joy when thinking about the year 1989.

But can the cause of today’s discontent be reduced to mistakes that were made in the course of the transformation? Hardly, one must distinguish. A look at the political circumstances in various countries of eastern Central Europe shows that, despite all the similarities in terms of these societies’ liberal or illiberal condition, there are great differences. One would almost like to paraphrase Tolstoy’s famous sentence: “All liberal democracies resemble each other; but every illiberal democracy is illiberal in its own particular way.”

There is no simple explanation why some countries of this region have trodden an exemplary democratic path today, for example Slovakia. In Poland, the criticism of the governing Law and Justice Party (PiS) focuses on the violation of elementary standards of the rule of law. In Hungary, the Fidesz Party of Viktor Orbán received so much support that he could achieve the alteration of the constitution that he wanted, fully legally. Nonetheless, it would be hard to speak of a lost battle for democracy in these countries. For example, in 2019 the Polish voters decided that the Senate should go to the opposition and the Sejm to the rightist-conservative PiS. In Hungary, an opposition politician won the election for Governing Mayor in Budapest – a triumph over Orbán.

At the same time, however, the success of populists in many Western countries – like Donald Trump in the USA and the Brexit-supporters in the United Kingdom – are all too reminiscent of what is happening in Poland and Hungary; we can not avoid to look for an explanation that applies to all these cases. At the base of this stands an aspect of human nature people like to overlook in politics, namely emotions. More precisely: it is about a feeling, a particular feeling – the feeling of loss.

If we think about societal changes, we like to focus on the gain that they will bring us. Our gaze falls more rarely on the social and personal costs. After 1989, millions of families in eastern Central Europe experienced simultaneously a dynamic upswing and a collective drama. Even if they were among the winners of the turnaround, the changes turned their lives inside out. It was a paradoxical and ambivalent experience. In Poland, which remained untouched by the financial and Euro crises of 2008, the resistance of a large part of the society against liberal democracy arose not despite its gigantic success, but rather – on the contrary – as a result of precisely this success. Just as, in his “A Tale of Two Cities” that played in 1789, Charles Dickens wrote of a “period of light and of darkness”, of the “spring of hope” and the “winter of despair”, the year 1989 brought revolutionary progress, manifested in the development of infrastructure, the increase in social mobility, and improvements in living standards, but a pervasive feeling of insecurity, on the other hand. Compact worlds of life fell apart, and even the self was lost.

The loss in question, thereby, has not only an eastern European, but also a global dimension. “1989” means not only the end of the epoch of communism, but also the beginning of an unprecedented acceleration. Globalization got going and with it world-spanning trade. Technological progress enabled formerly unimaginable mobility, as well as faster and more comprehensive communication – a development culminating in the Internet. To this came rising standards of living in many societies and a radical drop in child mortality.

One wants such progress, but at the same everything should remain as it was in the “good old days”. That’s why the Polish government constantly repeats that it will not allow the traditional family to be destroyed. And that’s why Trump won the elections with the slogan “Make America great again”. If illiberal, populist politicians enjoy great popularity, then less because their voters hate the opponents than because the former successfully tap into the reservoir of anger and frustration that is tied to the losses. Authors like Steven Pinker, who use statistical data to show that we live in the best of all worlds up to now, go unheard. They speak to the rational mind, populist politicians, outfitted with a sensitive feeling for disappointed hopes, growing resentment, and budding xenophobia, place their bets entirely on feelings.

Can there be a political answer to the feeling of loss that does not cast doubt on belief in liberal democracy and the rule of law? What would be needed is a new balance between the sentimental gaze at the past and the hopeful outlook on the future. Currently, the mythologizing gaze at the past has the upper hand. Fear of the future dominates, and what is lacking are positive visions for the coming decades that appeal to all. Technological utopias remain insufficient, because they leave people cold. Where breakneck progress becomes the rule, we will have to increasingly practice our dealings with losses. And this includes empathy and understanding: a person who is a victim of exclusion should be able to empathize with others: with ethnic and sexual minorities, but also with political opponents. Where societal dialog lives, liberal democracies stand solidly in the face of the authoritarian excesses of populism.

In 1946, George Orwell described in an essay a “new intellectual phenomenon” that he called “catastrophic gradualism”. This was the conviction that history obeys the principle of succeeding calamities and that each century is just as bad or almost as bad as the preceding one. Today the fairy tale of the inevitable victory of the populists is making the rounds. The belief in the freedom of the individual and with it in liberalism must be upheld. But this can be done only out of a deep trust in people’s ability for self-determination. The future must appear open and as an opportunity, if we don’t want to be sucked into the vortex of a dangerous determinism. Even the greatest magical moments of democracy, as 1989 was, would not have been possible without hope.

This texts is a shortened version of an article that appeared in the Neue Züricher Zeitung on 14 December 2019. It is printed here with the permission of the NZZ.Karolina Wigura and Jarosław Kuisz are heads of Kultura Liberalna, a media organization, think tank and NGO based in Poland, that promotes liberal and democratic values.You can contribute to Kultura Liberalna by making a donation.

  • Club
  • Membership
  • Newsletter
    • February 2023
    • March 2022
    • February 2021
    • March 2020
      • Editorial
      • Constitution as Nonviolent Revolution
      • Imre Kertész und die europäische Literatur der Gegenwart
      • A Profound Sense of Loss
      • The Wissenschaftskolleg and the East: The New Europe College in Bucharest
      • Save the date - Meeting of the Fellows’ Club - Biodiversity: Conceptual Challenges in an Era of Rapid Change, June 11 and 12, 2020
      • New Publications in the Fellows’ Library
      • Prizes
      • Join the Fellows’ Club
      • Obituarium
    • March 2019
    • March 2018
    • March 2017
    • June 2016
    • June 2015
    • December 2014
    • May 2014
    • November 2013
nn / Public domain

Institute for Advanced Study

  • Twitter
  • Press Releases
  • Contact Persons
  • Contact
  • Vacancies
  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap

Institute

  • Leadership
  • Committees
  • Contact Persons
  • The Kolleg
  • Initiatives & Cooperations
  • Library

Fellows

  • Fellowfinder
  • Fellows 2022/2023
  • Permanent Fellows
  • Alumni

Events

  • Calendar of Events
  • Lecture Recitals
  • Zur Zeit
  • Observatorium
  • Ernst Mayr Lecture
  • Workshops
  • Three Cultures Forum

Wikotheque

  • Wiko Shorts
  • Lectures & Keynotes
  • Features
  • Köpfe und Ideen
  • Projects
  • Yearbook
  • Zeitschrift für Ideengeschichte

Becoming a Fellow

  • Fellowships
  • Living and Working